The most common argument against a commodity money is that it doesn’t expand and contract with the “needs of trade.” The idea is that if the economy grows, the money supply should grow with it. Under the gold standard, increasing the supply of gold was slow and costly, so we needed to break away from those limitations with a system that allows for quick and low-cost increases in the money supply when warranted.
This argument was central to the founding of the Federal Reserve. In fact, it’s mentioned in the first sentence of the Federal Reserve Act: “An Act […] to furnish an elastic currency.”
The spirit of this argument was repeated when Congress endowed the Fed with its overarching policy goals: “[the Fed] shall maintain long run growth of the monetary and credit aggregates commensurate with the economy’s long run potential to increase production, so as to promote…




