Is Libertarianism Incoherent? | Mises Institute

0
127

In a recent Bleeding Heart Libertarian post, philosopher Matt Zwolinski tells us he can no longer “describe the core commitments of American libertarianism” as he could have just ten years ago. The reason, he says, is that the apparent consensus about libertarianism that emerged in the 1970s and started unraveling by the 1990s was just a temporary condition—an anomaly; libertarianism has otherwise been a shifting, evolving movement suffering “recurring bouts of fragmentation and re-fragmentation.”

Libertarianism has no “fixed philosophical essence,” Zwolinski says, or you wouldn’t have seen the drastic swings in how the term was applied between Déjacque’s anarcho-communism of the 1850s and Leonard Read’s free markets and limited government of the 1950s, let alone the present-day. There simply has never been a permanent, stable paradigm of liberty.

Yes, an apparent…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here