You Can’t Yell “Chicken Jockey” in a Crowded Theater (Except When You Can)

0
139

Some time ago, I wrote against the fallacious argument in favor of government censorship: that the government must legally restrict speech generally because “you can’t yell ‘fire!’ in a crowded theater.” One paper in William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal calls this “Constitutional Law’s Most Enduring Analogy.”

This argument has several problems: 1) the argument is a statist non sequitur that unnecessarily leaps to the requirement for state action; 2) the “fire in a theater” argument has never been used historically to literally argue that government must restrict speech in theaters, but instead to replace and bypass solid argumentation in order to justify general government censorship with a seemingly intractable problem. The “fire in a theater” argument is just a rhetorical attempt to obtain a password or cheat code, that is, provision of such a seemingly…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here