In The Constitution of Liberty, Friedrich Hayek argued that “mere legality in all government action” does not suffice as a basis for upholding the rule of law. Under a standard of mere legality, as long as a law is on the statute books, anything done in accordance with that law is legal. Mere legality also implies that as long as there is a plausible way of spinning state actions to bring them within the wording of a statute, that should suffice to make it legal. This would enable tyrants to read anything they want into the law, giving them a plausible foundation to depict all their actions as perfectly legal. Hayek warned that this would turn the law itself into a threat to individual liberty, which in his view would undermine the very purpose of the law. He agreed with John Locke that the purpose of law should be “to preserve and enlarge freedom.” Far from the law…




