Commentary
I have followed the Point Reyes ranching dispute for years, and, in the interest of full disclosure, I am on the ranchers’ side.
Not because I oppose conservation. Quite the opposite. I have dedicated much of my life to restoring soil, improving water cycles, planting trees, and producing food in ways that leave the land healthier than I found it.
I simply believe this story represents something much larger than a dispute over cattle. It is about whether California still believes agriculture belongs as a permanent part of its landscape.
For readers unfamiliar with the story, Point Reyes National Seashore was established by Congress in 1962. The federal government acquired ranches while allowing many existing ranching families to remain, as Congress envisioned agriculture as part of the park’s historic and cultural landscape.
Families who had been there for generations…




