Photo – Joshua Sukoff Shutterstock.com
By Johnny Tango CBNC News
Vice President JD Vance drew a hard line for American workers on Thursday, slapping down Oklahoma Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt’s push for a “bipartisan” immigration deal that would hand state work permits to illegal aliens whenever an employer vouches for them.
Vance did it in public, on X, Thursday morning, and he did not dress it up. “I like Kevin, but what does ‘bipartisan immigration reform’ mean?” he wrote. He said he was all for making it harder for megacompanies to defraud the visa system and harder for employers to break immigration law. Then he got to the point: “But to a lot of people, this sounds like an effort to give amnesty to people who have broken our laws. It is morally and electorally disastrous.”
Stitt had teed it up a day earlier at a POLITICO event on the sidelines of the National Governors Association’s New Governors Leadership Forum in Park City, Utah. The Oklahoma governor, who chairs the NGA alongside Maryland Democrat Wes Moore, urged President Donald Trump to spend his final two years working with Democrats on immigration. He repeated his long-running idea that governors, not Washington, should issue workforce permits to illegal aliens who hold jobs.
Stitt has laid out the mechanics before. “If a construction company is vouching for an employee, we should make that happen. We should give them a workforce permit,” he told Oklahoma public radio. He insists it is not citizenship, and he says anyone on welfare, Medicaid, or Medicare need not apply. That is the whole sales pitch: legal work status for people who entered or stayed illegally, signed off by the business that profits from hiring them.
In other words, the company that wants the cheap labor gets to write the hall pass for the cheap labor. That is like letting the fox run the henhouse security desk and then praising the fox for filling out the visitor log so neatly.
Stitt’s defenders will say this is just common sense for farms, hotels, and job sites that cannot find enough hands. The answer is the one Vance put on the table. Every permit handed to an illegal alien because an employer vouched for him is a job, and a wage level, that an American worker in Tulsa or Oklahoma City never got to compete for. A permit system built on employer say-so does not stop illegal hiring; it rewards it after the fact and tells the next employer to do the same.
The timing matters too. Democrats take control of Congress in January, and talk of a grand immigration bargain is already floating around Washington. Moderates in both parties want to call it reform. Vance just told Republicans in plain English what most of their voters will call it.
The country already ran this experiment in 1986, when amnesty was traded for enforcement that never came. Stitt is offering the same deal with a state seal on it. The man a heartbeat from the presidency just reminded him that the voters remember how that one ended.
Sources:
politico.com/news/2026/11/19/jd-vance-slams-republican-governor-immigration-01175617
usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2026/11/19/jd-vance-skeptical-bipartisan-immigration-reform/92861133007
washingtonexaminer.com/news/white-house/4809324/vance-kevin-stitt-disastrous-immigration-reform
kosu.org/kevin-stitt-immigration-approach




