Few historical episodes loom as large in the popular imagination of speculative excess as the Dutch tulip bubble of the 1630s. Tulipmania has become shorthand for irrational exuberance, a warning invoked whenever asset prices seem untethered from reality. Yet, as Austrian writers have long pointed out, the caricature of sober Dutch burghers mortgaging their estates for flowers is misleading.
Two apparently divergent interpretations have been offered within the Mises Institute orbit—Douglas French’s and my own—and as one commenter on Twitter recently put it, responding to myself: “Interesting and very confusing tbh Douglas French has extensive articles on mises.org regarding monetary expansion and the role of Duch [sic] central bank in this and you saying tgis [sic] is a myth. Not sure to whom to believe.”
In fact, rather than being mutually exclusive, these…




