Trump Sealed the Border. Now He Floats Amnesty For Illegal Aliens

0
106

By Zorina Grey CBNC News

The United States closed its southern border on President Donald Trump’s watch, and on Sunday the same president told 60 Minutes that his deportation drive had been “too tough” and that a deal granting legal status to illegal workers was on the table with the incoming Democratic Congress.

The remarks aired on CBS three days after Republicans lost control of the House and Senate. Trump recorded the interview Friday with correspondent Ross Douthat. He said the enforcement campaign “both helped and hurt” him, that he earned “an A+ for closing up the border,” and that he paid a price for removing people “that had good jobs” whose one violation was entering the country illegally. Asked whether an agreement with Democrats could create legal status for those workers, he said yes. He also said some officials inside his own administration, on what he called “the pretty far right,” want every illegal alien removed.

The claim now gaining ground in Washington is that an illegal worker who holds a job and pays some taxes has earned a collective right to remain, and that the country owes that group a legal path in return for its labor.

That claim fails first on incentives. A border is a promise about the future, and a legalization is a message to the next person deciding whether to cross. The 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act granted legal status to roughly 2.7 million people in exchange for enforcement that never fully arrived, and the illegal population that followed grew far larger than the one that was forgiven. Every foreign worker who watched 1986 learned that presence, not permission, is what Washington eventually rewards. A new amnesty would teach the same lesson to a world that is watching the same way.

The claim fails second on capacity. The administration spent the better part of two years building the detention space, the arrest tempo, and the removal agreements that made the border hold. Those systems exist because the law was enforced against everyone it covers. Carve out a protected class defined by employment and tax filings, and every case becomes a documentation fight that the federal government is not staffed to win. Employers who hired illegally would become the gatekeepers of who qualifies.

The claim fails third on American interest. The landscaping company and the hotel Trump described in the interview are the same sectors where American workers without college degrees compete for wages. A legal status pathway does not create new jobs for those Americans. It locks in the labor pool that held their wages down.

The political case for retreat rests on one exit poll. CBS reported that 58 percent of voters believe the immigration crackdown went too far. The same poll found voters still trust Republicans over Democrats on immigration, 43 percent to 41 percent. The party that lost Congress still holds the advantage on the issue it is now being urged to surrender.

The contradiction sits inside the White House itself. On Friday, Trump promoted Stephen Miller, the architect of the mass deportation program, to chief of staff. Two days later, the president told a national audience that the program Miller built was too harsh and that he would like to negotiate its partial reversal with Democrats who will hold the gavels in January. The border is closed today. The question the next Congress will answer is whether the United States keeps it closed or pays the cost of reopening it on credit.

Sources:

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here