A federal appeals court threw out the ISIS material support conviction of the man who detonated a pipe bomb inside a New York City subway passage in 2017, ruling that consuming terrorist propaganda online does not amount to working under a terror group’s control.
The Second Circuit voted 2-1 on Tuesday to reverse that single count against Akayed Ullah. The court left his remaining convictions intact, including for carrying out a terrorist attack on a mass transit system, the New York Times (NYT) reported. Ullah strapped a homemade explosive to his body and set it off during the morning commute on Dec. 11, 2017, in a corridor between the Times Square and Port Authority stations.
Ullah told a detective at the hospital that he acted on behalf of ISIS and had watched the group’s propaganda videos on YouTube, according to the NYT. Investigators found an ISIS slogan written…




