Fifty years ago today, the SS Edmund Fitzgerald sank. For any child of the Great Lakes growing up in the 1990s, as I did, the event is infamous; not only because Gordon Lightfoot’s song was constantly played on soft rock stations. The sinking of the ship was a marker between the Midwest as a Factory Belt and the Midwest as a Rust Belt. Hauling ore from the Iron Range in Minnesota to iron works in Michigan, those famous last lines from Captain McSorley captured perfectly the Midwestern reserve in the face of adversity: “We are holding our own.”
Having spent a lifetime reading about the shipwreck, I now see the event as a true tragedy. Only a few miles behind the Edmund Fitzgerald was the SS Arthur Anderson, which survived the storm that produced wind gusts over 80 miles per hour and waves of up to 25 feet. The storm was a feared November Witch, created when a low…




