Commentary
When I first encountered music of the Renaissance, one piece stood out to me for its soaring and eternal beauty which I found unfathomable. The piece was called “Miserere mei” and the composer was Gregorio Allegri who lived from 1582 to 1652, hence a life in composition overlapping with much more famous people like Claudio Monteverdi. This is pretty much the only composition for which he is known.
It is a haunting polyphonic setting of the text “Have mercy on me, O God,” that is at once simple—what’s called falsobordone, or harmonized chant, not as complex as others of the 1630s were composing—but also with this mysterious eternal reach. It features a soaring high C in the soprano part that sounds like a cry of pain, a plea for mercy, or an angel granting grace; it’s not clear which. Regardless, one cannot stop listening.
Then you encounter the urban legend,…




