Kevin Del Aguila, David Patrick Kelly, and Ahmad Simmons in The Fantasticks, at the Hayes.
Photo: Joan Marcus
Try to remember the first time you experienced The Fantasticks. Even if you haven’t, you may still know its opening song, so different from the lollapaloozas that start most contemporary musicals — a simple, sweetly melancholy ballad earnestly asking the audience to suspend not so much our disbelief as our sophistication. It has the rare quality of sounding like a song that was somehow happened upon rather than written, and it’s not the only tune in the show — still, at 42 years Off Broadway, the record holder for longest-running musical anywhere ever — to evoke that feeling. Tom Jones (book and lyrics) and…



