For many Americans, even lovers of American history, myself included, there are certain blank spots and gaps in knowledge. While we can appreciate that history can be and is used propagandistically to affirm certain narratives—usually by emphasis and deemphasis—it is also often the case that time constraints and desire to focus on other events helps create these gaps. One common gap is the period between the American Revolution and the Philadelphia Convention.
The commonly-accepted—but little-scrutinized—view of this period is that the Americans won their independence, but that lack of strong national government created chaos. However, the situation was remedied by the Constitution and its new form of government. Obviously, tacit acceptance of such a narrative defaults to the implicit assumption that liberty and decentralization lead to destructive disorder, but centralization…




