Clinton-Appointed Judge Blocks Trump Administration’s Narrow Definition of “Medically Frail” for Medicaid Work Rules

0
125

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns, appointed by President Bill Clinton, held on October 29 that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services guidance defining “medically frail” for the new Medicaid community-engagement requirement is contrary to law. The holding appears in a sixteen-page order issued in the District of Massachusetts. Stearns granted partial relief to a coalition of twenty-five Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia. He ordered the agency to remove the requirement that a qualifying condition must “significantly impair” the individual’s ability to meet the eighty-hour monthly work, volunteer, or education standard. He also stayed enforcement of medical-frailty determinations for six months.

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, enacted in 2025, requires most able-bodied adults ages 19 to 64 who receive Medicaid through the Affordable Care Act expansion to complete eighty hours per month of work, community service, or half-time education beginning January 1. Congress listed five categories of people who are exempt as “medically frail,” including those who are blind, have a disabling mental disorder, or have another complex medical condition. In June the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services issued an interim final rule that added the further limitation that the condition must significantly impair the ability to comply with the engagement requirement. The rule also restricted the documents states could accept to claims data no older than twelve months.

Stearns found that the agency lacked authority to exclude any subset of the five categories Congress had already designated. He wrote that enforcement of the narrower definition “may lead to the disenrollment of otherwise eligible vulnerable individuals relying on Medicaid coverage for continuity of care.” He rejected the states’ remaining challenges, including their objection to the twelve-month documentation limit and the one-time self-attestation rule. The work requirement itself remains intact. Only the additional impairment language was set aside.

The American cost is the continued enrollment of individuals who meet one of the statutory categories but cannot demonstrate the further impairment the agency demanded. States that sued argued the narrower rule would force costly system changes and risk coverage losses for people already in care. The administration argued the rule simply implemented the statute’s intent that the exemption apply to those too sick to work. Stearns sided with the states on the statutory-text point and with the administration on the documentation and attestation points.

No Supreme Court scorecard applies. The case remains in the district court. The order is a partial injunction against a single provision of an interim final rule, not a final merits judgment on the underlying work requirement. The appointing president of the judge is Bill Clinton. The holding is limited to the “significantly impairs” language and the accompanying six-month stay on frailty determinations.

Sources: https://justthenews.com/government/courts-law/judge-blocks-part-trumps-proposed-medicaid-work-rules https://www.politico.com/news/2026/10/29/judge-strikes-down-trump-admins-definition-of-medically-frail-in-medicaid-work-rules-01140696 https://kffhealthnews.org/morning-breakout/medicaid-and-costs-103026/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here