The point of the College Football Playoff should be to determine which college football team is the best in the nation.
To some ears, this might sound obvious. To some, it might sound reductive. But if we embrace this premise, then here is a conclusion that follows:
No team should be in a college football playoff that does not have a plausible claim to be the best team in college football.
HOW THE SUPREME COURT BROKE COLLEGE FOOTBALL
I repeat: The CFP shouldn’t be the 12 or eight or four best teams in college football — it should be every team with a plausible claim to be the single best team in college football.
There is nobody who believes James Madison University has the best college football team in the country. Likewise, it’s basically impossible to argue that Alabama’s team is the best in the country.
In an ideal system, neither of these teams would be in…




