Supreme Court Leaves California’s 20,000 Disputed Ballots in the Count After Clinton-Appointed Judge Rejected Segregation

0
115

The Supreme Court denied the Trump administration’s emergency application for an injunction that would have required California to segregate roughly 20,000 mail ballots from voters the Department of Justice identified as likely noncitizens. The one-sentence order, issued Monday evening, November 2, 2026, on the eve of the midterm elections, contained no reasoning and recorded no public dissents. The application had been presented to Justice Elena Kagan, the circuit justice for the Ninth Circuit, and referred to the full Court. The holding is that the federal government will not obtain interim relief to keep those ballots separate while citizenship is verified.

The case began in mid-October when the Justice Department sued California in the Central District. Officials alleged that a multi-agency review of voter files against immigration, passport, and Social Security records produced a list of more than 20,000 individuals who appeared registered and who were likely not U.S. citizens. California mails a ballot to every active registered voter. The Department asked the court to order the state to set those ballots aside—not cancel them—until citizenship could be confirmed, arguing that once the ballots are commingled the dilution of lawful votes cannot be undone. U.S. District Judge David Carter, appointed by President Bill Clinton, denied the temporary restraining order on October 28. In a 26-page opinion he wrote that the request “would wreak havoc and disrupt the election” and that the government’s methodology was vague and raised reliability questions. He noted that the Department had reduced an earlier figure of nearly 191,000 names to approximately 20,000 and that Los Angeles County sampling showed substantial rates of already-canceled or inactive records.

The Ninth Circuit affirmed in a 2-1 decision. Judges Mark Bennett (appointed by President Trump) and Gabriel Sanchez (appointed by President Biden) formed the majority. Judge Patrick Bumatay dissented, stating that the federal government possesses a sovereign interest in the integrity of federal elections and that both state and federal law prohibit noncitizen voting. Solicitor General D. John Sauer then filed the emergency application with the Supreme Court, seeking a limited order that California segregate the challenged ballots pending full merits review. Sauer argued that federal law bars noncitizens from voting in federal elections and that the Supremacy Clause requires state officials to accommodate that prohibition. The Court denied the application without asking California to respond.

No justice publicly dissented. The America First side—the side seeking to prevent unverified ballots from being counted alongside verified ones—received zero recorded votes from the Court. The practical result is that California continues to process and tabulate the ballots under state procedures. The Department of Justice has already charged 28 green-card holders in California with illegal registration or voting; all 28 appeared on the flagged list and 11 have been arrested. Those prosecutions proceed independently of the civil segregation request.

The American cost is the dilution risk that remains unaddressed for the duration of the count. Federal statute makes noncitizen voting a crime. The administration sought only a temporary administrative step—segregation for verification—rather than wholesale disqualification. Lower-court judges appointed by Presidents Clinton and Biden rejected that step. The Supreme Court left the rejection in place on the final day before polls closed. The scorecard for the emergency application is 0-9 against the request to keep the ballots separate. The holding stands: no interim segregation. The ballots remain in the count under California’s existing rules.

Sources: https://justthenews.com/government/courts-law/scotus-rejects-trump-admins-attempt-set-aside-california-ballots-it-believes https://redstate.com/jenvanlaar/2026/11/02/it-looks-like-the-dispute-over-likely-noncitizens-on-cas-voter-rolls-is-going-to-scotus-n2208832 https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/11/trump-administration-asks-supreme-court-to-intervene-in-california-ballots-dispute/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here