Rothbard and Eminent Domain: Confused History and Legal Sleight of Hand

0
100

One of the striking features of American constitutional law is how little argument is devoted to some of its most coercive doctrines. Few examples illustrate this better than eminent domain. In contemporary jurisprudence, the power of the state to seize private property is treated not merely as legitimate, but as axiomatic: an inherent attribute of sovereignty, requiring no justification beyond procedural regularity and “just compensation.” That this power should be assumed rather than argued for is itself revealing. As Murray Rothbard recognized, eminent domain is less the product of common-law development or constitutional reasoning than of historical confusion and legal sleight of hand.

Rothbard addressed eminent domain most directly in The Ethics of Liberty, though his critique is consistent with arguments he made elsewhere regarding taxation, conscription, and regulation…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here