George P. Fletcher is widely regarded as an authority in criminal law, and he has taught at Columbia University Law School for many years. He is also an authority on Kant’s moral philosophy and, contrary to the secular views of most of his contemporaries, is interested in the religious origins of our belief in moral rights. In addition, although he is firmly committed to equality—understanding this in the modern sense as including the Civil Rights Act of 1964—as well as welfare and social rights, and in his book Our Secret Constitution: How Lincoln Redefined American Democracy (Oxford University Press, 2002), he also makes an honest effort to understand the Southern point of view before the War Between the States, albeit strongly rejecting it. An unusual combination of views, you must admit; and the book contains many provocative arguments. In what follows, I will comment on a…




