instruments capable of restraining political power. Particularly following the Renaissance and Enlightenment, written constitutions began to be celebrated by limited government political theorists as rational devices designed to bind rulers, limit coercion, and protect liberty through clearly-enumerated rules.
Yet a persistent strain of skepticism—articulated most sharply by thinkers such as Murray Rothbard and Ralph Raico—has questioned whether constitutions can ever perform this task in practice. Far from constraining power, they recognize, constitutions tend to be reinterpreted, circumvented, or absorbed into expanding state structures once they conflict with the incentives of those who govern.
Rather than restating this argument in the abstract, we will examine three historical case studies—Republican Rome, medieval Florence, and 20th-century England—to demonstrate how…




