By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News
Senior U.S. District Judge William J. Martinez, appointed by President Barack Obama, denied a preliminary injunction on November 4, 2026, leaving Colorado’s permit-to-purchase scheme for specified semiautomatic firearms in force while Del Toro v. Polis proceeds. The holding is that the plaintiffs did not show a substantial likelihood of success on their Second Amendment claim, and therefore did not show the irreparable injury required to freeze the law while the case is pending.
The motion asked the court to block only Sections Two and Three of Senate Bill 25-003, which took effect on August 1, 2026. Those provisions make it unlawful to sell or purchase a “specified semiautomatic firearm,” including semiautomatic rifles and shotguns with detachable magazines, unless the buyer has completed state-approved training. Gov. Jared Polis, a Democrat, signed the broader act on April 10, 2025. The law also restricts “rapid-fire devices,” but that ban was not before the court on this motion.
Before enrolling in a required course, a buyer must obtain a firearms safety course eligibility card from a county sheriff and then complete an in-person class taught by a sheriff-verified instructor. A sheriff “shall” issue the card to an applicant who submits the required materials, and “may” deny it on a reasonable belief that documented previous behavior makes it likely the applicant will present a danger to themselves or others.
Martinez agreed that the individual plaintiffs are among “the people” protected by the Second Amendment and that the right to keep and bear arms includes a right to acquire them. He stopped the claim at the next element. The plaintiffs argued that Colorado’s definition sweeps in more than 800 models, including the AR-15, which the Supreme Court in 2025 called the most popular rifle in America. The judge wrote that common use is a necessary condition for Second Amendment protection, not a sufficient one. “In other words, if a gun is not in common use, then it is not protected by the Second Amendment; but the reverse is not also true,” the order states. He found that the plaintiffs had not shown that the specified semiautomatic firearms are arms commonly used today for self-defense.
The order notes that federal appeals courts are split on whether semiautomatic rifles are protected arms and that the Supreme Court is likely to resolve the question this term in Viramontes v. Cook County. Until that happens, a judge in Denver concluded that popularity alone did not carry the plaintiffs through the first step of the analysis required by New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen.
The court gave a second, independent reason for denying relief. Even if the firearms were protected, Martinez found that the scheme is a shall-issue licensing regime of the kind Bruen and District of Columbia v. Heller treat as presumptively constitutional. He rejected the argument that a sheriff’s narrow authority to deny a card on a belief of danger converts the law into a discretionary may-issue system, writing that “discretion under SB25-003 is the exception, not the rule.” He also found that the plaintiffs had not shown the scheme was “put toward abusive ends” through endless delays or exorbitant fees. State figures as of September 1, 2026, showed 3,574 applications, 1,125 eligibility cards issued by 39 county sheriffs, an average of 10.9 days from application to card, and 502 people who finished the course, with none failing the exam.
The plaintiffs are Israel Del Toro, Luke Sorensen, Nathanael Skiver, Jason Reeves, Garrett Flicker, and the Colorado State Shooting Association, which the order describes as the official state association of the National Rifle Association. Huey Laugesen, the shooting association’s executive director, called the court’s rationale “simply insane” and said the idea that the most commonly owned firearms in America fail to qualify as arms under the Second Amendment is extraordinary. “We believe this law is unconstitutional, and will keep fighting until Coloradans’ Second Amendment rights are restored,” he said.
The order is preliminary. It does not decide the merits, and the state’s motion to dismiss remains pending. The law that requires a sheriff’s card and a state-written course before a Coloradan may buy a common semiautomatic rifle remains in effect.
Sources
https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/israel-del-toro-jared-polis-order.pdf
https://www.thecentersquare.com/colorado/article_3180cbfe-6db4-4b68-ba14-cbae932fd219.html
https://www.usacarry.com/federal-judge-says-gun-owners-failed-to-prove-ar-15s-are-protected-arms-refuses-to-block-colorados-semiauto-permit-to-purchase-scheme/
https://www.fjc.gov/history/judges/martinez-william-joseph




