Ninth Circuit Stays Clinton-Appointed Judge’s Abortion Injunction and Restores Idaho’s Defense of Life Act

0
133

Photo Michael Vi/Shutterstock.com

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued a stay on October 30, 2026, that lets Idaho enforce its Defense of Life Act while the appeal proceeds. The order suspends the injunction entered by Senior District Judge B. Lynn Winmill, a 1995 Clinton appointee, in Seyb v. Members of the Idaho Board of Medicine. Winmill had ruled that Idaho’s near-total abortion ban violated the Fourteenth Amendment by failing to supply broader health exceptions that would let a physician exercise personal medical judgment, including the ordinary risks of a cesarean section. The three-judge panel held that the defendants—Attorney General Raúl Labrador and Ada County Prosecuting Attorney Jan Bennetts—had shown a strong likelihood of success on the merits because the plaintiff, Dr. Stacy Seyb, is unlikely to reconcile the district court’s view of history and tradition with the Supreme Court’s holding in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization.

The holding is limited but clear. The stay is not a final merits decision. It restores the status quo that Idaho’s elected legislature wrote and that the Idaho Supreme Court has already interpreted. The panel majority, consisting of Circuit Judges Consuelo Callahan and Kim Wardlaw, concluded that the state’s interest in enforcing its law would suffer irreparable harm if the injunction remained in place. Judge Marsha Berzon dissented. No Supreme Court justices participated; the scorecard of justices who voted against the America First side is therefore empty on this order. The only judicial actor who expanded the abortion right beyond Dobbs is the Clinton-appointed district judge whose injunction the circuit has now paused.

Winmill took senior status in 2021 after twenty-six years on the District of Idaho. He was nominated by President Clinton after a bipartisan screening process recommended by Idaho’s then-senators. In the Seyb case he conducted a bench trial and issued an amended memorandum decision on February 26, 2026, that treated maternal mental-health risks and the possibility of a cesarean as sufficient grounds for an abortion. Labrador appealed the same day and sought an emergency stay. The Ninth Circuit granted a temporary stay in early September, heard argument on September 22, and issued the full stay pending appeal on October 30. Labrador’s statement after the order was direct: Idaho’s unwavering protection for unborn children and their mothers will continue as intended.

The American cost is measured in the space the injunction tried to occupy. Idaho’s pregnancy-related mortality rate fell after Dobbs. The state’s voters and legislature chose a near-total ban with a life exception. A single district judge substituted a broader health standard that the Supreme Court had returned to the people. The Ninth Circuit’s stay returns that choice to Idaho while the appeal is litigated. The plaintiff may still prevail on the full record. The temporary order simply refuses to treat a Clinton-appointed judge’s reading of the Fourteenth Amendment as the final word before the circuit and, if necessary, the Supreme Court have spoken.

Sources: https://justthenews.com/government/courts-law/9th-circuit-rules-idaho-can-proceed-pro-life-laws-while-appeals-process-plays https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/us-court-lifts-ruling-requiring-idaho-allow-some-abortions-protect-womens-health-2026-10-30/ https://www.lifenews.com/2026/10/30/appeals-court-rules-idaho-can-enforce-abortion-ban-save-babies/ https://www.ag.idaho.gov/newsroom/ag-labrador-appeals-ruling-that-would-let-doctors-override-idahos-pro-life-law/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here