Marx Was Wrong About the “Necessary” Ruin of Small Landed Property

0
104

Marx believed that once land is subjected to private property and competition, the superior economics of large-scale ownership will necessarily ruin and absorb the small proprietor. That sounds dramatic. It is also bad economics. The claim treats scale as a one-way ratchet and ignores everything that makes real markets real: rising managerial costs, local knowledge, entrepreneurial discovery, heterogeneous land, and the ever-present role of state privilege. In a genuine market order, land does not move automatically to the largest owner. It moves—imperfectly, but decisively—toward those who can use it best under particular conditions, and those conditions often favor smaller owners rather than swallowing them.

Ronald Coase supplied the first devastating answer to Marx’s “inevitability” thesis. A firm does not grow forever simply because scale can lower some costs. It expands…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here