Biden Judge Refuses to Let Trump’s Justice Department Call Off Her Courtroom Interrogation of Chicago’s Top Federal Prosecutor and Orders U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros Onto the Witness Stand With Criminal Contempt on the Table

0
161

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

U.S. District Judge April Perry, appointed by President Joe Biden, refused on Wednesday, November 11, 2026, to let President Donald Trump’s Justice Department narrow or cancel a hearing at which Chicago U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and three of his assistant prosecutors must answer her questions under oath, holding that her inherent authority over the lawyers who practice before her is enough to compel the testimony. The hearing remains set for Monday, November 16, at the Dirksen U.S. Courthouse in Chicago, and Perry has said her inquiry could end in sanctions or a referral for criminal contempt.

Perry ruled in a minute order entered on the public docket the morning after Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the third-ranking official at the Justice Department, filed what the department called a motion for clarification. Woodward asked the judge to identify the legal authority for the hearing and to consider “limiting or forgoing entirely this inquiry.” He argued that “no authority exists for a federal judge to hold a mini-trial” built to gather evidence while criminal sanctions are in play, and he proposed that the court step aside and leave the matter to the Executive Branch, which could conduct its own internal review.

Perry rejected that position. She wrote that the government’s “professed lack of clarity” about her power to question lawyers who misstated facts to the court “is immaterial.” She also questioned the department’s standing to object at all, noting that it does not represent at least three of the four people she ordered to testify and that nothing on the docket shows it represents Boutros. Two of the assistant prosecutors, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez, have told the court through their own lawyers that they are ready to testify. The third is William Hogan.

Woodward put the Fifth Amendment squarely on the record. He wrote that the court had handed the prosecutors a “Catch-22,” in which they could either testify and risk prosecution or invoke their right against self-incrimination and risk antagonizing the judge. According to the Chicago Sun-Times, it was the second time in six weeks that a department official has left that possibility open.

The criminal case behind the dispute no longer exists. The “Broadview Six” were protesters, among them Democrat congressional candidate Kat Abughazaleh, who were indicted on a felony conspiracy charge after prosecutors said they surrounded and pushed against an ICE agent’s vehicle outside the immigration facility in Broadview, Illinois, in September 2025, during Operation Midway Blitz. The grand jury declined to indict on October 9, 2025, and returned the indictment on October 23. Boutros dropped every charge in May 2026 after Perry found apparent misconduct before the grand jury by the veteran prosecutor who presented the case, Sheri Mecklenburg.

Perry is now testing two statements made to her by the Chicago office. Boutros told her he learned of the grand jury problems only in late April, but he later acknowledged receiving an October 14, 2025, email that attached a transcript documenting them, and he says he does not remember reading it. Perry demanded the email’s metadata and read receipts. On Tuesday she said the department had produced two one-page PDF files with no metadata, called its privilege log “noncompliant” because it names no author or recipient, and gave it until 3 p.m. Thursday to correct the production.

The second statement came from Hogan, who wrote in a March 30 filing that there had been “no communications of any nature” with anyone outside the Chicago office about charging decisions, and that this specifically included the White House and Justice Department headquarters. A September correction acknowledged contacts with headquarters after the charging decision, and the department is now asserting privilege over outside communications instead of denying that they occurred.

The legal question is who polices a federal prosecutor. Federal judges have long claimed inherent power to sanction abuse of the judicial process. The Justice Department’s position is that once a judge’s inquiry carries the threat of criminal contempt, it begins to resemble a prosecution, and prosecution belongs to the executive. Woodward has not yet formally challenged Perry’s November 2 order requiring Boutros to testify, though the Sun-Times reported that a challenge appears likely before he takes the stand.

Under the procedure Perry set on Wednesday, each witness may give an uninterrupted oral statement or submit a written statement signed under oath, after which she will question them herself, with no cross-examination. Unless a higher court intervenes, the chief federal prosecutor for the Northern District of Illinois will sit in a witness chair on Monday in the same building where his office brings its cases, and he will be answering to a Biden-appointed judge rather than to his superiors at the Department of Justice.

Sources
https://dnyuz.com/2026/11/11/judge-shuts-down-trump-dojs-effort-to-derail-prosecutor-misconduct-hearing/
https://www.arcamax.com/currentnews/newsheadlines/s-4342506
https://chicago.suntimes.com/politics/2026/11/10/broadview-six-boutros-perry-stanley-woodward
https://chicago.suntimes.com/politics/2026/11/02/broadview-six-boutros-perry
https://news.wttw.com/2026/11/02/judge-orders-chicago-us-attorney-andrew-boutros-testify-botched-broadview-six
https://chicago.suntimes.com/immigration/2026/05/21/broadview-ice-protest-grand-jury-transcript-kat-abughazaleh-trump
https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/charges-dismissed-broadview-six-grand-jury-transcript/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here