Why Sovereign Immunity Remains Paramount
The Commission is proposing to channel up to €140 billion of frozen Russian central bank assets into a complex “bond-for-collateral” scheme designed to support Ukraine’s war effort. However, the legal aspect of the plan raises too many questions.
At the heart of the global legal order lies the principle of state sovereignty — one nation cannot impose its jurisdiction on another without its consent (par in parem non habet imperium). This results in jurisdictional immunity, including immunity from execution. The International Court of Justice, the European Court of Human Rights, and EU courts have all consistently affirmed that sovereign assets, especially those held by central banks, are immune from seizure unless they are demonstrably being used for commercial purposes.
Article 21 of the UN Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities…




