Carney’s Paper Plan Leaves the North Door Open While He Courts Brussels

0
119

By Johnny Tango CBNC News

Mark Carney wants Canadians to believe a 13-page framework will protect the border and the paycheck. It will not. The Plan for a Stronger Canada, released Thursday, is the first national security strategy in more than twenty years. It runs thin on pages and thinner on numbers that matter to a trucker in Calgary or a homeowner in Windsor. The document lists eight strategic capabilities—emerging technologies, critical minerals, defence, energy, transportation, pharmaceuticals, food security, and payments—and tells the country to prepare for all contingencies up to and including war. It calls for a disciplined foreign policy that diversifies partnerships. That is the boast. The cost is that ordinary Canadians keep writing the checks while the northern border stays porous and the largest customer keeps getting treated like the problem.

Carney rolled the strategy out in Montreal while he hosted European Union leaders. Ursula von der Leyen talked about association without accession. Carney used the associate-member phrasing himself. Officials later scrubbed the exact label from the joint declaration after Germany and others balked at a status that does not exist in EU treaties. The summit still aims at deeper alignment on climate, energy, AI, and security rules. Canada already sits inside CETA. The new pitch is to reduce reliance on the United States under tariff pressure. Carney has said the open global trading system is challenged and that deep integration has become a vulnerability. He wants strategic autonomy. Canadians get the bill for the autonomy theater.

The plan commits Canada to the NATO path that reaches 5 percent of GDP on defence by 2035. Current spending sits at 2 percent. Budget 2025 already put $10.9 billion over five years into digital infrastructure for National Defence, the Canadian Armed Forces, and the Communications Security Establishment. A new Defence Investment Agency is supposed to speed procurement. The strategy says a first ministers meeting on national security will come later and that detailed policies on defence, foreign affairs, economic security, public safety, and intelligence will follow. Within a year Ottawa will propose modernized national-security legislation. That is a lot of future planning. Michelle Rempel Garner, the Conservative immigration critic, called the document extremely weak and noted it is silent on security screening for non-citizens. CSIS screening requests for people seeking to enter Canada hit a record 538,000 in 2024. The Canada Border Services Agency screening inventory sits around 195,000 cases. Permanent-residence files referred for full screening are projected to take years. Rempel pointed to the Ahmed Eldidi case—an individual who entered in 2018, passed screenings, became a citizen in 2024, and was later charged with ISIS-related terrorism offences tied to a video that had been online for years. The strategy does not fix that pipeline.

Alberta voters rejected separation this month but passed the immigration questions. Roughly 53 percent supported greater provincial control to bring numbers to sustainable levels. Carney has said Ottawa has retaken control of immigration and will not budge from sustainable levels. He has not ruled out a Quebec-style deal for Alberta. Quebec already selects its own economic immigrants under a 1991 accord. The rest of the country still watches overall targets that earlier Liberal budgets said would stabilize permanent residents below one percent of population after 2027 and cut temporary residents from a 2024 peak of 7.6 percent. The security plan does not spell out how the screening backlog shrinks while those numbers move.

Energy is listed as a strategic capability. Pacific Link, the one-million-barrel-a-day line from Alberta to the West Coast, carries an estimated cost of C$35.2 billion to C$43.7 billion, with taxpayers expected to shoulder most of it. Ottawa and Alberta signed an MOU that cancels the oil-and-gas emissions cap and aims at higher production. Ninety percent of Canadian crude still heads to the United States. Carney has said the new pipe will materially reduce that dependence by opening Asian markets. The same week he is in Montreal talking European association, the message to Washington is diversification first. American refiners configured for heavy Canadian crude have been the reliable buyer. The strategy treats that reliability as a structural vulnerability rather than a fact of geography and capital investment. Ordinary Canadians pay the public share of the pipeline and the defence ramp-up. Ordinary Americans lose the nearest, most secure heavy-oil supply if the diversification talk turns into delayed volumes.

The plan mentions a cooperative, clear-eyed relationship with the United States based on mutual respect and shared responsibility for North American security. It also lists Europe as a priority for deepened connections and the Indo-Pacific for trade. Carney has already opened the first military talks with China in eight years while trade talks with Washington remain stalled. The strategy says the line between economic security and national security has disappeared. That line disappeared for Canadian households years ago when housing, grocery, and energy costs rose under high immigration and green mandates. The new paper does not reverse those pressures. It adds another layer of planning.

Tango has seen this pattern before. A former Bank of England governor who learned his manners in the City arrives home, talks sovereignty, and shops a closer seat with Brussels while the northern border takes returns the United States will not warehouse. The strategy prepares for war on paper. It does not close the screening gaps Rempel named or guarantee that Pacific Link steel goes in the ground before the next election cycle. Canadians keep the higher taxes and the uncertain energy markets. Americans keep a neighbor whose prime minister treats the largest bilateral relationship as something to manage around rather than the foundation it is. That is the cost of the autonomy boast.

Sources:
https://www.canada.ca/en/privy-council/services/publications/plan-stronger-canada/national-security-canadians.html
https://www.pm.gc.ca/en/news/news-releases/2026/10/29/prime-minister-carney-launches-plan-stronger-canada-strengthen
https://www.reuters.com/world/carney-host-european-union-officials-draft-declaration-avoids-associate-member-2026-10-28/
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/european-union-canada-associate-member-von-der-leyen-9.7400922

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here