
By Bill Dobbs CBNC Business News
America’s goods deficit with Canada widened again. Statistics Canada reported Nov. 4, 2026 that Canada’s merchandise trade surplus with the United States jumped to $12.3 billion in September 2026 from $12.1 billion in August. That Canadian surplus is a U.S. goods deficit. Ottawa books the win. American factories, haulers, and taxpayers carry the load.
What happened is plain. Canada’s overall goods surplus hit $5.4 billion in September, up from $5.0 billion in August — the largest in four years under Financial Post framing. Canadian exports to the United States rose 0.7 percent. Imports from the United States rose 0.4 percent. Export volumes, measured in real terms, dropped 4.0 percent overall. Strip out energy and metals and Canadian exports fell 5.6 percent. Prices and energy/gold shipments propped the surplus. Volume did not roar. The bilateral imbalance with America still widened.
Why? Tariff war, stalled talks, and a surplus model Ottawa still refuses to settle on U.S. terms. Section 338 / 50 percent U.S. tariffs hit roughly CA$27.6 billion in Canadian goods effective Aug. 22, 2026 after talks collapsed. Ottawa answered Sept. 8 with retaliatory tariffs on about CA$27.6 billion in U.S. imports at 15, 25, and 50 percent rates. RBC put the average effective U.S. tariff rate on Canadian imports at 4.2 percent in the latest flash, up from 3.2 percent in August, with roughly 82 percent of Canadian exports still duty-free under CUSMA. Formal talks remain stalled. On Nov. 4, The Epoch Times reported Canada-U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc saying Ottawa’s strategy sits unchanged after the U.S. midterms. Mark Carney said some red lines shifted. Strategy did not.
Who paid? American plants that lose shipment share. American haulers that move fewer northbound loads when retaliation bites. American buyers who eat higher prices when tariffs and counter-tariffs stack on goods. American taxpayers who fund the enforcement fight while Ottawa celebrates a $12.3 billion bilateral surplus. A surplus for Canada is a deficit for the United States. Jobs, wages, and paychecks on this side of the border feel that math.
USTR and Just the News context make the longer arc clear. The 2025 U.S. goods deficit with Canada fell more than 25 percent to $46.4 billion. The deficit with Mexico that same year stood at $196.9 billion, up 14.8 percent. Progress against Canada’s imbalance is not a finished job when September 2026 still prints a $12.3 billion Canadian surplus with America. President Trump, per June 2026 Just the News reporting, is not looking to renew USMCA and wants surpluses, not deficits. That stance collides with Ottawa’s unchanged strategy after the midterms.
Energy and gold propped Canada’s September export story. Real export volumes fell. Excluding energy and metals, exports dropped harder at 5.6 percent. Price effects and commodity shipments widened the bilateral surplus even as volumes softened. American factories competing in those lanes do not get a parade. They get a wider deficit line and a tariff fight Ottawa still will not close on American terms.
Strong verbs fit the ledger. The surplus widened. Talks stalled. Volumes dropped. Retaliation jumped onto U.S. imports. Effective tariff rates rose. Strategy stuck. Main Street did not welcome any of it. Plants need shipments. Haulers need loads. Workers need wages that outrun prices. Mortgage and savings pressure do not ease when a neighbor books a $12.3 billion surplus against American goods trade and leaves formal talks frozen.
America First trade means surpluses for American producers, not permanent deficits dressed up as a partner’s win. Canada’s September 2026 merchandise surplus with the United States at $12.3 billion — released Nov. 4, 2026 — is the American cost in one number. Overall Canadian goods surplus at $5.4 billion does not change the bilateral truth. Exports to the U.S. edged up 0.7 percent. Imports from the U.S. edged up 0.4 percent. The gap favored Ottawa. The load hit American factories and paychecks.
Debt and deficit are not free. Every month of widened Canadian surplus against U.S. goods trade is a month American plants, haulers, and taxpayers carry the imbalance and the tariff war. Stop treating Ottawa’s surplus boast as neutral news. Attribute the surplus. State the American deficit. Demand terms that close the gap, restart real talks, and put American jobs, wages, prices, and factory shipments first. Until then, Canada’s win remains Main Street’s load.
Sources:
- https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/261104/dq261104a-eng.htm
- https://financialpost.com/economy/canada-trade-surplus-with-u-s-widens-despite-new-tariffs/
- https://justthenews.com/nation/economy/trump-turns-usmca-trade-tensions-deficits-bring-north-american-trade-pact-brink
- https://www.theepochtimes.com/world/canada-us-trade-minister-says-ottawas-strategy-on-trade-unchanged-after-us-midterm-results-6118103
- https://www.rbc.com/en/economics/canadian-analysis/data-flashes/canadian-trade-surplus-widens-on-prices-as-new-u-s-tariffs-set-in/
Visual



