A federal judge has thrown out the Trump administration’s Title IX lawsuit against California — not because she found the state’s policy fair, but because she found the paperwork insufficient. That distinction matters, and it’s the entire story.
U.S. District Judge Cynthia Valenzuela, a Biden appointee sitting in the Central District of California, dismissed the Department of Justice’s case with prejudice this week, ruling that the federal government never gave California clear enough notice that its transgender athlete policy could cost the state $44.3 billion in education funding.
Under Spending Clause doctrine, Washington cannot retroactively punish a state for violating a condition it never explicitly spelled out. That legal technicality, not the underlying…




