Not all of my cast iron cookware is as spoiled as my everyday Lodge skillet. While it sees me through Saturday night steaks and weeknight sautés all year, other pieces — like my double Dutch oven, muffin pan, and loaf pan — often only see the dark ends of my cabinets. On a few occasions, I’ve pulled my cast iron out of those cabinets and found rust encroaching on what I thought was impenetrable seasoning. And after I asked experts for their opinions, I understand why the rust formed.
According to chefs and a professional organizer, the most common, rust-promoting mistake you can make is nesting cast iron cookware together, as I was doing. “That is fine,” says Kent Rollins, star of Cast Iron Cowboy, “but you need to put a buffer in between, like a cotton dishcloth or pot holder, so there won’t be any scratching of the seasoning.” He adds that you should never…




