In 1994, Andrew McMahon got to see his first-ever concert: Billy Joel at the Richfield Coliseum in Cleveland. He was in sixth grade, and his parents gifted him tickets to the River of Dreams tour for Christmas. “As soon as I started playing the piano, my parents gave me Billy Joel’s Greatest Hits – Volume I & Volume II,” he tells Rolling Stone over the phone. “They were like, ‘OK, if you’re going to be a piano singer-songwriter, this is your study material.’”
More than three decades later, McMahon found himself at Carnegie Hall on March 12, performing “Piano Man” at The Music of Billy Joel, a tribute concert honoring the legend. McMahon had opened for Joel in 2017, but this was a full-circle moment he’d never experienced before. Not only was it his first time performing at the iconic New York City venue, but Joel himself was watchingfrom the opera…




