Alito Off the Boulder Climate Case. No Vote.

0
172

By Jennifer Sanchez

No vote has been cast. Justice Samuel Alito, appointed by George W. Bush, is off Suncor Energy Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, docket 25-170. Clerk Scott Harris told counsel on Sept. 28 that Alito “will not continue to participate.” The letter gave no reason. A recusal is a recusal.

The question the companies brought up is whether federal law preempts state-law tort suits that seek money from oil and gas firms for local climate harm. Boulder County and the City of Boulder sued Suncor entities and ExxonMobil in April 2018. The Colorado Supreme Court, in May 2025, held that federal law did not preempt the claims and that they could proceed under state law. The companies say no state tort theory reaches this conduct. Kannon K. Shanmugam argues for the energy side. Kevin Russell of Russell & Woofter argues for Boulder. Argument audio is scheduled on the Court’s stream.

Alito’s exit landed after a May letter from left-leaning watchdog groups asked the Senate Judiciary Committee to look at his oil and gas holdings and noted he had recused from an earlier petition involving the same companies. A Court spokeswoman told NBC News then that Alito had no financial interest in any party and that the Court’s counsel had advised recusal was not required. Harris was more specific in January, when Alito left Chevron USA v. Plaquemines Parish: a financial interest in ConocoPhillips, parent of a firm that remained a party below. This letter is not that letter. The code the justices adopted in November 2023 tells a justice to step aside when impartiality might reasonably be questioned, including a financial interest in a party or in the subject matter. It does not require a public reason.

Similar municipal suits are pending in other states. A ruling that state tort claims are preempted stops them in federal court. A ruling that they are not sends Boulder back to Colorado procedure and leaves the other complaints where they sit. The Court granted the case on Feb. 23, 2026. Eight justices sit for this morning’s 10 a.m. Eastern argument, the first of the term. Counsel should not read that bench as a forecast. A tie affirms the judgment below by default. That is arithmetic, not a holding.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here