The late-nineteenth and early twentieth-century philosopher F. H. Bradley is not at the center of contemporary philosophical discussion, but he was, in my opinion, one of the greats, and, in his book Ethical Studies (first published in 1876) he raises some important questions criticisms of utilitarianism, mainly of the sort favored by John Stuart Mill and Henry Sidgwick. The topic should be of interest to Rothbardians, because Murray Rothbard was also strongly opposed to utilitarianism. Bradley wrote in an old-fashioned style that may not be to the taste of modern readers, but he often expressed himself with great literary power and grace.
Utilitarianism calls for us to maximize happiness, and Bradley’s first point against this is that people can’t specify what happiness is: “Alas! The one question which no one can answer is, What is happiness?—which everyone in the end can…




