A Rawlsian Trick | Mises Institute

0
101

In A Theory of Justice (Harvard University Press, 1971), the philosopher John Rawls proposed an account of justice that, in his view, was better than the competing theories, viz., utilitarianism, which says you should act by what will lead to the best consequences, and “deontological” theories that appealed to rights. Opponents of utilitarianism raised various problems for it, e.g., that applying it sometimes led to counterintuitive results. In an often-discussed example, if a doctor could kill an accident victim and then distribute his vital organs to five donors in need of a transplant, utilitarians seem to be committed to accept this as the best course of conduct, since doing so saves four lives on net. (Utilitarians came up with various ways to get around this result, but it was still thought to be a problem).

In the absence of a competing acceptable theory, though, most…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here