The Juridical Model of Justice

0
199

In Shakespeare’s Henry VI, a rebel alarmingly named Dick the Butcher says: “The first thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers.” But wait—don’t we need lawyers to safeguard the rule of law and uphold justice? In his essays on justice, the philosopher Chaim Perelman set out to “analyze scientifically the concept of justice.” His aim was “to distinguish the variety of its meanings and uses,” revealing the ambiguity and conceptual confusion that pervades the quest for justice. He observed that, despite belief in justice under the law, lawyers traditionally saw justice simply as “conformity to the law.” In their view, “not violating the law is the accepted way of implementing justice.”

But what if the law itself is unjust? Philosophers concerned with justice therefore doubted the ability of lawyers to answer such “higher” abstract questions. Perelman…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here