Are tomatoes a fruit or a vegetable? While some may have different answers to this mostly lighthearted question, at one point in time it was taken up by the United States Supreme Court. Despite its seemingly amusing aspects, the story of Nix v. Hedden is one which has implications for those concerned with big government and the challenges of reform, while also providing a unique window into late-nineteenth century American politics. This is especially relevant as tariffs have remained a meaningful topic during the Trump era.
The origin of the Supreme Court’s involvement with tomatoes was tied with tariff laws. While arguments about tariff rates were rooted in American political disputes since the very beginning of the US, the situation was noticeably impacted by the Civil War. The conflict was transformative in a litany of ways, and this included increases in the nation’s tariff…




