By Bill Dobbs CBNC Business News
$28.15 billion. That is how far American purchases from Mexico outran American sales to Mexico in September 2026 alone, a record for one month. America bought $62.24 billion of Mexican goods. Mexico bought $34.09 billion of ours. On Thursday the president said he would double the tariffs on Mexico. The question for Main Street is simple: who writes the check?
Start with the boast. “MEXICO MUST STOP THEM, NOW, and if they do not do so, the Tariffs on Mexico will be IMMEDIATELY DOUBLED,” President Trump posted on Truth Social Thursday morning, Nov. 12. The target is a migrant caravan of roughly 1,500 people, mostly Central Americans, that left Tapachula near the Guatemala border on Tuesday, Fox News reported. The post named no deadline.
The border is a real fight, and Mexico should carry its share of it. But a tariff is not a fine mailed to Mexico City. It is a tax collected at the American port of entry from the American importer of record. Then it moves down the line to the plant, the hauler, the dealer and the family at the register.
What happened? Trade with Mexico exploded. Two-way commerce hit a record $96.34 billion in September, up 34.2% from a year earlier, per WorldCity figures reported by FreightWaves. Imports from Mexico jumped 39.6%. Exports to Mexico rose 25.4%. Imports grew faster. The gap widened. Mexico is now America’s biggest trading partner by $31.6 billion over Canada.
Why did it happen? Read the tape at the border, not the press release. Laredo, Texas, moved $38.87 billion of trade in September, and $26.87 billion of it was coming north. Santa Teresa, New Mexico, more than tripled, up 248.5%. FreightWaves tied the surge to manufactured goods, electronics and transportation equipment. That is factory work, and the finished product is rolling north to American buyers. Census data show the national deficit with Mexico set a record in September, along with record deficits with Vietnam, Taiwan, South Korea, Malaysia and Italy.
Who paid? Here is what the tariff fight has already cost. After the Supreme Court threw out the IEEPA emergency tariffs in February, American importers lined up for refunds. More than $115 billion has gone back through Customs as of August. Class counsel told the Court of International Trade this week that $166 billion is owed in total, to more than 330,000 importers of record, Fortune reported Thursday. The administration is fighting to pay only the companies that sued. Read that again. Those duties were paid by American companies. Small importers without lawyers are still waiting for their money.
Now the read, labeled as the read. Today most Mexican goods that qualify under USMCA cross duty-free. Goods that do not qualify pay normal duty plus a 10% Section 301 levy. Steel, aluminum, vehicles and parts still face Section 232 duties. Bloomberg Law noted it is not clear what legal authority the White House would use to double anything after the Supreme Court ruling. Here is the simple arithmetic. If an extra 10 points ever landed on a month of Mexican imports the size of September’s, it would be $6.2 billion a month collected from American buyers. That is illustrative math, not a forecast. But that is the scale.
And the talks are stuck. U.S.-Mexico negotiations stalled in October over steel and aluminum after Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick tried to take over the talks, Transport Topics reported. A new threat on top of a stalled deal does not shrink a $28 billion gap. It adds uncertainty to every truck at Laredo.
Is a doubled tariff the fix? No. The fix is bringing the plants home so that $62 billion of goods gets made by American workers on American payrolls. A tariff that sends the bill to an Ohio parts buyer or a Texas retailer without moving a single production line north is a tax on Americans, not on Mexico. Washington should keep the pressure on the border. It should stop calling the import tax a win until the deficit line moves. Main Street is keeping score.
Sources
- https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trump-threatens-double-tariffs-mexico-migrant-caravans-not-stopped
- https://nypost.com/2026/11/12/us-news/trump-threatens-to-double-mexico-tariffs-if-migrant-caravan-reaches-us/
- https://www.ttnews.com/articles/trump-double-tariffs-mexico
- https://www.freightwaves.com/news/mexico-widens-us-trade-lead-with-record-96-3b-september
- https://www.strtrade.com/trade-news-resources/str-trade-report/november/trade-deficit-stays-high-as-exports-grow-faster-than-imports
- https://fortune.com/2026/11/12/tariff-refund-class-action-lawsuit-universal-tariff-refunds-trump-administration/
- https://news.bloomberglaw.com/international-trade/trump-threatens-to-double-tariffs-on-mexican-goods-over-migrants




