It is by no means uncommon to hear someone reply to criticism of his conduct by saying that there was no law against it. This is a sinister reply, at least implicitly, for it suggests that what the law does not forbid is permitted in all other senses: in other words, that the law provides the sole criteria by which we are to judge our conduct. No doubt there are some legislators who would be delighted by this extension of their responsibilities, but for anyone who cares both for freedom and civilization, the idea of such philosopher kings (who always turn out to be ambitious mediocrities) sends shivers up the spine.
It was Lord Moulton, an English judge, who coined the felicitous phrase “obedience to the unenforceable” more than a century ago. These are the standards of behaviour that the law does not enforce, either by…




