Being Better Than Someone Worse Doesn’t Make You Good

0
108

Commentary

Have you noticed how often people evaluate their conduct by comparing themselves with others?

Imagine a driver who is cut off by another motorist. The driver may respond, “I’m not a perfect driver, but at least I’m not like that person!” People use the same logic when discussing morality: “I’m not perfect, but at least I’m not like him.” They may compare themselves with someone who committed a notorious crime and say, “I may have flaws, but at least I’m not a serial killer or a master thief.”

Avoiding such crimes is obviously good, but judging ourselves by people who behave worse is not a meaningful moral standard. The fact that someone else has done something terrible tells us nothing about whether we are acting justly, honestly, or compassionately.

Philosophers often describe this outlook as moral minimalism or threshold morality. It defines morality…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here