By Paul Engel
July 29, 2026
- Does Roundup cause cancer?
- Can states regulate commerce within their own borders?
- Can federal law override both state law and the Constitution?
I’ve heard a lot of people talking about the Monsanto case and the claims that one of their products, Roundup, may cause cancer. However, the case before the Supreme Court was much more unique, involving state’s rights, intrastate commerce, and the limits of federal law and regulation.
Background
Whether you think Roundup causes cancer or is perfectly safe, do you have a right to sue for an allegation that it does? More specially for the case of Monsanto v. Durnell, can federal law prohibit you from suing in state court? That is the question before the Supreme Court.
Monsanto Company manufactures and distributes Roundup, a glyphosate-based herbicide designed to control weeds. The EPA has repeatedly…




