Rothbard on The Calculus of Consent

0
146

James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock’s The Calculus of Consent is usually considered a classic of free-market thought, but Rothbard was not an admirer of it. In a memo, now conveniently available in Rothbard’s Economic Controversies, prepared in 1960 for the Volker Fund on a manuscript version of the book, he raises some fundamental questions about it, and in this week’s article, I’d like to discuss some of these.

As everybody knows, Rothbard’s defense of libertarianism is based on natural rights. Buchanan and Tullock rejected natural rights, instead relying on a unanimity rule. In essence, if everybody within a society agrees at a “constitutional stage” to adopt a framework in which people can associate and work out their conflicts, isn’t this in effect just as good as natural rights, but without the philosophical baggage? After all, if you are in the society, and…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here