In this American Spectator article, Elliot Resnick argues that Tucker Carlson’s blanket claim that Christians may never kill innocents in war does not reflect the historic Christian just war tradition.
- Resnick opens by citing Tucker Carlson’s recent argument that killing innocents is never acceptable under any circumstances by any person or nation.
- The article contends that Carlson is presenting a form of Christian pacifism as if it were mainstream Christian teaching.
- Resnick points to St. Augustine and later Christian thinkers to argue that Christian just war thought has historically allowed civilian deaths under certain wartime conditions.
- The article references the Crusades and medieval warfare to show that Christian armies have not historically operated under Carlson’s absolutist moral standard.
- Resnick distinguishes between deliberately targeting innocents and…




