Willmoore Kendall (1909-1967) was an editor of National Review, though he later broke with the magazine’s founder and editor, William F. Buckley, Jr. Murray Rothbard devoted critical attention to him, and I have sometimes written critically about him myself. This is not the most promising background for a favorable review, one must acknowledge; but he was a Southerner from Oklahoma, and—in a review of the Straussian Harry Jaffa’s Crisis of the House Divided—he offers forceful criticism of Jaffa’s portrayal of Lincoln as an egalitarian and a defense of the Southern position in the War Between the States.
The review first appeared in National Review and is reprinted in Kendall’s book The Conservative Affirmation (1963) from which I quote. Kendall identifies the heart of Jaffa’s interpretation of Lincoln, the meaning of the equality clause in the Declaration of Independence,…




