Photo: Balazs Gardi for New York Magazine
For Jon Bernthal & Co., getting this play to the stage will be a lot like pulling off a bank heist. The 49-year-old actor is in only his second week of rehearsals for his Broadway debut, the first theatrical adaptation of Dog Day Afternoon, and the show is scheduled for technical rehearsals the following week. He’s blocking out scenes from this sweaty powder keg of a story in a rehearsal space downtown during one of the coldest winters in New York memory. “It takes me back to living here in the early 2000s,” he tells me during a brief break, “where times were tough and all I wanted was to be onstage.”
Bernthal plays Sonny, the character made famous by Al Pacino in Sidney…




