Over the past decade, a number of social democrats and left-libertarians have taken to claiming that open borders would be an unmitigated boon for any country that allows limitless numbers of foreigners into its territory. For example, open-borders advocate Bryan Caplan states that a failure to open borders is like leaving “trillion-dollar bills on the sidewalk.” In their pursuit of a vision for open borders that might strike ordinary people as remotely desirable, Caplan and other open-border activists put forward a thought experiment in which millions—or even billions—of human beings would relocate across nation-state borders over a span of a few years and in the process unleash the potential of the world’s economies.
In terms of economic theory, the assumption here is that there is a mismatch between the location of capital and the location of labor. If labor is allowed…




