The Illogic of Reparations: Historical Standards, Selective Memory, and the Logic of Victory

0
189

The modern argument for reparations rests on the retroactive application of legal and moral standards that did not exist when slavery was practiced. Slavery in the United States was legal for centuries. Although morally contested, it was not unlawful, and when the institution was abolished, the formerly enslaved were not compensated for their bondage. Their emancipation did not bring financial restitution, nor were slaveholders punished for actions that had been legal under the governing system of the time. Since compensation was not granted when the injustice was most immediate, it is difficult to justify granting it more than a century and a half later. The reparations argument therefore depends on projecting present moral sensibilities backward into a society that did not operate under those standards.

Moreover, once one examines the movement more closely, its selective nature…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here