Are Any Peoples Truly Indigenous?

0
93

October 13 this year is Columbus Day (observed) in the United States, a day referred to by some as “Indigenous Peoples’ Day.” Right on schedule, we’re seeing all the usual media posts—in both social media and old media—asserting that land should be controlled by those who are indigenous to it. 

This raises the question of what it means to be “indigenous”—a status generally premised on the we-were-here-first claim—which implies a right of ownership. That implied right to ownership, in turn, is premised on a presumption that the alleged indigenous group homesteaded the land in question—by virtue of being the first to occupy it. Or, put in more colloquial terms, ownership is premised on the moral theory known as “finders keepers.”

But, there are some problems and ambiguities with the we-were-here-first claim as it is usually made. Indeed, the problems are found…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here