On a podcast called “Raging Moderates,” Hillary Clinton recently said, “The Supreme Court will hear a case about same-sex marriage. My prediction is they will do to gay marriage what they did to abortion. They will send it back to the states.” This is one time that you can’t say, of the onetime Goldwater Girl, “What’s she been smoking?”
SCOTUS has a chance to overrule Obergefell v. Hodges, in a case that it might or might not take this term (although chances are it won’t). Whether this term or some future term, the justices, along with the public, need to accurately apprehend the logical lay of the land.
It looks like this: If same-sex couples are similarly situated to opposite-sex couples, then (as in Obergefell) state laws banning same-sex civil marriage should be struck down; conversely, if same-sex and opposite-sex couples are not similarly situated, then…




