Bret Stephens Is Wrong About Mortality in Gaza

0
137

The New York Times columnist Bret Stephens recently claimed that Israel is “manifestly not committing genocide”. His key argument is that if Israel were committing genocide, the war would have been “vastly more deadly”. In actual fact, he notes, the death toll reported by the Gaza Health Ministry is around 60,000—not particularly large by the standards of modern warfare.

Stephens’s argument is flawed. The evidence we have indicates that the war in Gaza is very deadly indeed. (While establishing whether Israel is committing genocide is beyond the present author’s expertise, numerous genocide scholars and human rights organisations believe that it is.)

To begin with, the Gaza Health Ministry’s figure excludes those who died of disease or starvation, as well as those who have been reported missing. It is therefore a substantial undercount.

In a…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here