Since the election of Pope Leo XIV, a strange argument about the work of the Holy Spirit and God’s sovereignty is floating around on Catholic X, and it goes a little something like this:
I’m not here to pick on Matt Walsh, who’s just one of many people making this argument. But since we do need to have a “conversation about the pope,” that conversation must include the pope’s “modern political” views because, unfortunately, then-Bishop Robert Prevost chose to make those views part of the conversation by (re)tweeting about them for years. For a decade-plus, Prevost posted and reposted left-wing talking points about George Floyd, gun control, global warming, immigration, race relations, Donald Trump, J.D. Vance, and more. Pointing that out isn’t a “gotcha game” or a troll. Because our theology informs our politics, a person’s politics can…




