By Bash Harvey CBNC News
Four California Democrats in the House want illegal aliens who already lost in immigration court to stay in the country and collect green cards. Rep. Lateefah Simon, Rep. John Garamendi, Rep. Zoe Lofgren, and Rep. Juan Vargas introduced the Protect Our Neighbors Act on November 19, and the bill does exactly what the title hides.
Picture the process it erases. An illegal alien gets a hearing. A federal immigration judge hears the case and orders removal. Under this bill, if that person simply stays put, stays continuously present, and avoids a criminal conviction for ten years, the removal order expires. Then the bill opens a pathway to apply for lawful permanent residence. The reward for ignoring a final order becomes the green card.
The bill, H.R. 11120, has been referred to the House Judiciary Committee. Simon’s office puts the number of people living in the United States with final orders of removal at roughly 1.19 million. That is the size of the line this bill would move to the front.
The sponsors frame it as mercy. Simon says no one should live in fear of being torn from family after years of building a life here, and she says she is sick of the Trump administration targeting neighbors.
Here is the verified fact on the other side. A post-midterm Economist and YouGov survey, taken November 13 to 16 among 1,628 U.S. citizens, found 51 percent of Americans want most illegal aliens deported, including 23 percent who want all of them removed immediately. Another 41 percent said those who commit serious crimes should go. Only 7 percent said all should be allowed to stay. Even among Democrats, only 11 percent took that position.
The Simon bill does not just side with the 7 percent. It goes past them. It takes the people a judge already ordered out and hands them a timer that ends in permanent residency.
This is not a one-off. House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries said this week that his party will move the Dream and Promise Act early in the next Congress, when Democrats take control of the House. The Protect Our Neighbors Act shows where that road leads once the floor belongs to them: the final order stops being final.
Washington will call this compassion and reform. In the rest of the country, people who follow the law, wait in line, and respect a court order when it goes against them will see something else. They will see a system where the ruling of a federal immigration judge carries an expiration date, and where the people who walked away from that ruling get the prize.
The cost lands on every legal immigrant who did it the right way and on every taxpayer who funded the hearings. Ten years of defiance becomes a qualification. A court order becomes a suggestion. And four members of Congress from one state are asking the whole country to sign off on it.
Sources:
simon.house.gov/media/press-releases/congresswoman-simon-introduces-new-immigration-bill-protect-community-members
congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/11120
breitbart.com/immigration/2026/11/20/poll-americans-still-say-most-illegal-aliens-should-be-deported-only-7-believe-all-should-stay
breitbart.news/democrats-introduce-amnesty-for-illegals-with-final-deportation-orders-2




