Fifth Circuit Rules Second Amendment Protects Gun Sales

0
29

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

The Second Amendment protects the sale of firearms, a Fifth Circuit panel held, with Judge James C. Ho, appointed by President Donald Trump, and Judge Andrew S. Oldham, appointed by President Donald Trump, voting to vacate the denial of a Louisiana man’s constitutional challenge to federal dealer licensing, over a dissent from Judge Catharina Haynes, appointed by President George W. Bush.

The case is United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, filed November 19. Jeremiah Micah Deare was indicted for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal license under 18 U.S.C. Section 922(a)(1), along with false statements on licensed dealer records. He moved to dismiss, arguing that the licensing and record-keeping requirements violate the Second Amendment.

The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Louisiana denied the motion. It held that licensing rules for sellers do not touch an individual’s right to keep and bear arms and that, in any event, they fit the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. A jury convicted Deare on all counts, and he was sentenced to 97 months in prison.

The panel’s unsigned opinion rejected the lower court’s threshold reasoning. It held that the plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms, relying on the circuit’s earlier statement in Reese v. ATF that the right to keep and bear arms surely implies the right to purchase them. The opinion also noted that the government conceded at oral argument that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms. The panel vacated the order denying dismissal and sent the case back.

The panel did not decide whether Section 922(a)(1) survives the historical analysis required by the Supreme Court in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen. That question now returns to the district court.

Ho wrote a concurrence answering the dissent directly. He noted that the dissent’s view, that the Second Amendment does not mention sellers, would logically strip booksellers of First Amendment protection, a result no court would accept. Constitutional rights, he wrote, are meaningless if the government can simply prohibit the means by which citizens exercise them.

Oldham, joined by Ho, concurred in the judgment and went further. He wrote that restricting the sale of firearms plainly infringes the right, both for the seller and for the buyer, because the right to keep an item includes the right to acquire it. He also wrote that the circuit’s 2025 decision in United States v. Peterson, which read Bruen to presume shall-issue licensing schemes constitutional, was wrongly decided and should be overruled. He directed the district court to follow Elite Precision Customs v. ATF, a 2026 Fifth Circuit decision that enjoined enforcement of parts of Section 922(a), and to ignore Peterson, which the Justice Department had cited to call Section 922(a) presumptively constitutional.

Haynes dissented. She wrote that she does not believe gun sellers are covered by the Second Amendment, that the rules applied to Deare were sufficient and proper, and that she would simply affirm the conviction.

The ruling binds federal courts in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. Federal prosecutors in those states now face a circuit holding that the commercial sale of firearms sits inside the constitutional text, which means every licensing prosecution must be defended on history rather than waved through on the theory that sellers have no rights at all.

Scorecard: Judge Catharina Haynes, appointed by President George W. Bush, dissented and would have affirmed.

Sources:
breitbart.com/2nd-amendment/2026/11/20/fifth-circuit-panel-firearm-sales-are-protected-by-second-amendment
ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/24/24-30241-CR0.pdf
reason.com/volokh/2026/11/20/second-amendment-as-a-right-to-sell-guns-as-well-as-to-have-and-buy-them
grable.law/post/fifth-circuit-deare-second-amendment-firearm-sales

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here